The Logic of Doubt

October, 2011 - An excerpt from my story


 My brothers do not be dismayed when you face trials of many kinds for you know that the testing of your faith develops perseverance and perseverance hope, and hope makes not ashamed because the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Spirit who is in us (Romans 5:4-5). 


I used to have a much stronger sense of faith. I knew that the beliefs I had were right, that the principles I believed were true, that the actions I took were appropriate, and that those things I dismissed as false had no relevance to my life.

 In the process of change, I have forced myself to remain open to new ideas, to new ways of life, and to new knowledge. Now, I have a choice before me to continue this openness. Does staying open require me to doubt what I already know? Do my actions in acquiring knowledge require me to abandon what I already believe?

 I think that I want to believe that what I believe is truth is actually true and then build my life and justify my actions by it.  However, I do not want to cut myself off into another bubble of self-created, self-justified truth that only I believe and that is actually false.  

 Recently I have realized that I thought my trust in Jesus was absolutely at the core of who I am. I thought that I chose to trust in Him instead of in my own reason and knowledge. However, I made that decision to trust with full knowledge and reason of what it meant. Therefore I still have grounds to question whether I made a wise or a foolish decision. At times I feel it was the best choice I ever made. At other times, I wonder if there could be another choice. I live my life by the decision I’ve made, but I do not stop wondering if another way could be better.

I suppose part of the reason for this doubt is my constant pursuit of the truth – or what I think is the truth - that exists out there somewhere yet beyond my reach.  I still think I need to find it; still think I need to have a more complete knowledge of what is not truth in order to fully appreciate what I believe is truth.

Perhaps I assume that what I believe becomes for me that which is true. Specifically, I define truth in my mind, then believe this truth with my heart. Because of this assumption, I don’t trust what I believe to be true. Or at least some part of me doesn’t.

I want to believe, want to be secure, and want to know the truth. One part of me says that when I find the truth I will believe it. Another part of me wants to believe that I already know the truth and wonders why I constantly doubt whether I actually do know the truth. Yet a third part of me wants to be apathetic and not really care whether I know the truth or not – after all life is about living, not knowing.

"Life is not about the right answers, but about the right relationship" – Molly Reich